Sterling Silver - What You Need to Know

THE CONSCIOUS SHOPPER'S GUIDE TO PRECIOUS METALS (Part 3)

Why tarnishing is normal (and actually a good thing!), plus your complete guide to silver jewelry

While gold gets most of the attention, sterling silver offers its own unique beauty and energy. As a more accessible precious metal, silver is often the gateway into fine jewelry—but it comes with its own set of characteristics that can confuse new buyers.

The most common question I hear about silver? "Why is my jewelry turning black?" The answer might surprise you: tarnishing is not only normal, it's actually a sign that you have real silver!

 

The Truth About Tarnishing

Here's what jewelry sellers might not tell you: silver tarnishing is completely natural and actually indicates quality.

Why silver tarnishes: Silver (specifically, the presence of copper in the alloy) reacts with sulfur compounds in the air, creating a thin layer of silver sulfide on the surface. This appears as a dark or black coating.

What affects tarnishing speed:

The good news: Tarnishing is only surface-deep and completely reversible. It doesn't damage your jewelry—it's simply a natural reaction that can be easily cleaned.

Why tarnishing indicates quality: If your "silver" jewelry never tarnishes, it's likely silver-plated or not real silver at all. Genuine sterling silver will always tarnish over time.

 

Understanding Different Types of Silver

When you're properly educated about silver, you can shop confidently, knowing how to identify authentic materials, rather than cheap imitations. The markings, in particular, help you identify exactly what type of silver you're purchasing, which is crucial for understanding care requirements, expected durability, and value.

 

Sterling Silver (925): The Popular Girl

Sterling silver is the most common form of real silver, and you probably have lots of pieces that are sterling.

What it is: 92.5% pure silver, 7.5% other metals (usually copper)

Why the alloy: Pure silver, like pure gold, is too soft for most jewelry. The small amount of copper adds strength and durability while maintaining silver's beautiful appearance.

How to identify it: Look for stamps like "925," "Sterling," "SS," or "Ster"

Price point: Much more affordable than gold, making it accessible for building a collection

 

Fine Silver (999): The Pure Option

A complete piece is rarely made from fine silver due to its softness. Most jewelers use fine silver for bezel settings (a thin metal rim that encircles a gemstone with a sleek, modern look), because it's easier to push down securely without fracturing the stone. Fine silver also melts beautifully without pitting and is a favorite for embellishments and granulation (little silver balls).

What it is: 99.9% pure silver

Characteristics:

• Doesn't tarnish (or tarnishes very slowly)
• Very soft and malleable
• Bright, white appearance
• More expensive than sterling

How to identify it: Look for stamps like "999," ".999," "Fine Silver," or "FS"

Best for:

• Artistic jewelry
• Wire work
• Special occasion pieces
• Bezels and/or jewelry embellishments
• People who want to avoid tarnishing entirely

Consider this: While fine silver doesn't tarnish, it's much softer and more prone to scratching and denting than sterling silver.

 

Argentium Silver: The Modern Innovation

Argentium is a trademarked alloy created by Argentium Silver Company, and the markings are especially important to note in this case. The stylized unicorn head logo is their official mark, but not all pieces will have it.

What it is: 93.5% pure silver with germanium instead of copper as the primary alloy

Characteristics:

• Extremely tarnish-resistant (tarnishes much more slowly than sterling)
• Harder and more durable than sterling silver
• Maintains bright white appearance longer
• Self-healing properties (minor scratches can disappear with heat)

How to identify it: Look for stamps like "Argentium," "AG," "935" or "940," or the distinctive Argentium unicorn head

Best for:

• People who love silver but hate tarnishing
• Active lifestyles requiring durability
• White metal lovers who want maximum brightness

Consider this: More expensive than sterling silver but offers significant practical advantages. Still a relatively newer option, so not all jewelers work with it yet.

 

Silver-Plated vs. Sterling Silver

Just like with gold, there's a big difference between solid sterling silver and silver-plated jewelry:

Sterling Silver:

 

Silver-Plated:

Caring for Your Sterling Silver

The key to beautiful silver jewelry is understanding that some maintenance is normal and healthy...

Daily Care:

Storage:

Cleaning:

Never use:

The Beauty of Patina

Here's something many people don't realize: some tarnishing can actually enhance silver jewelry's beauty. A light patina in recessed areas creates depth and character, especially in textured or detailed pieces.

Many jewelry designers (including me!) intentionally oxidize (darken) silver to create contrast and highlight design elements. This isn't damage—it's an artistic choice that shows silver's versatility. (It also saves you from constantly polishing to remove tarnish!)

 

When to Choose Silver Over Gold

Silver might be the perfect choice if you:

Love cool tones: Silver complements cool skin undertones beautifully

Want to build a collection: Lower price point allows for more pieces

Enjoy maintenance rituals: Some people find cleaning and caring for silver meditative

Prefer versatility: Silver works with almost any color palette

Have a bohemian or modern aesthetic: Silver fits these styles perfectly

Want to layer: Silver pieces layer beautifully together

Desire fine jewelry on a tight budget: Silver is a much more affordable precious metal

Silver and Gemstones

Silver is an excellent setting for gemstones, especially:

Investment Perspective

While silver doesn't hold value like gold, quality sterling silver pieces can last generations with proper care. The key is buying well-made pieces from reputable sources rather than mass-produced items.

Consider sterling silver jewelry as:

Red Flags When Buying Silver

Avoid pieces that:

Quality indicators:

Embracing Silver's Character

Unlike gold, which maintains its appearance with minimal care, silver develops character over time. Learning to work with silver's natural tendencies—rather than fighting them—helps you appreciate this beautiful metal's unique qualities.

Your silver jewelry will tell the story of your life: pieces you wear often will stay bright from the oils in your skin, while occasional pieces might develop a romantic patina. Both are beautiful in their own way.

Next week: We'll wrap up our series with essential questions to ask before buying any precious metal jewelry, plus a complete confidence-building shopping checklist.

 

RELATED POSTS:

Want to read the other posts in this informative series: Check out...

Part 1: Why That "Gold" Bracelet Costs $45 (And Why Its "Twin" Costs $450)

Part 2: Gold Karat Guide - Understanding 10K, 14K, 18K and 24K

Part 4: Smart Shopping - Questions to Ask Before You Buy